10 Beloved TV Shows That Will Likely Never Come Back (Despite All The Recent Reboots)

With an immense number of reboots and revivals resurging some of television’s most iconic shows, there are a number of shows that most likely will never see the small screen again. Reboots and revivals are, for better or worse, at the forefront of television programming. As networks bring back classic shows with new casts and updates for modern audiences, they walk a fine line between capitalizing on nostalgia and tarnishing the legacy of an original. For every successful reboot like Will & Grace or Twin Peaks that recaptures the magic of earlier seasons, there are misfires, like the short-lived Heroes reboot or Netflix’s polarizing fourth and fifth season of Arrested Development.

Still, the formula has proven tempting to both networks and viewers alike, with reboots radically reshaping both current programming and expectations of what shows could potentially return. However, despite the number of revivals currently seeing the light of day, some classics remain firmly in the past, whether due to the show’s popularity or fear that the brilliant moments of the original could not be recreated. As more blasts from the past show up on both streaming and cable, a few gems now only live on in reruns and box sets, their glory undimmed by failed attempts to rekindle the spark.

10 Murder, She Wrote

A show better revisited through reruns

Considered one of the best procedural TV shows, Murder, She Wrote holds an enduring place in television history, yet a reboot is unlikely to ever materialize. Original star Angela Lansbury staunchly opposed revival plans, arguing that the show’s idyllic Cabot Cove setting and Jessica Fletcher’s wholesome character couldn’t be recaptured today (via BBC). Without that formula of charming characters inhabiting a small town, a reboot would likely fail to resonate with loyal fans. The alluring concept is still intriguing, but Lansbury’s concerns ring too true that the lighthearted whodunits belong to another time, best revisited through reruns.

9 The Sopranos

Recapturing that alchemy seems an impossible task

Universally acclaimed as one of the greatest TV dramas ever made, The Sopranos captured lightning in a bottle with its portrait of the modern American mafia. However, the mob drama is unlikely to work if rebooted for contemporary audiences. The Sopranos drew intrigue by presenting an aging institution struggling with the complexities of 21st century life. With the novelty of the mafia genre now diminished and public fascination with organized crime fading, that crucial appeal would be lost in a reboot. On top of the improbability of again reaching such towering prestige, the mob no longer holds the same mystique that enabled The Sopranos to dissect it so incisively.

Related

10 TV Shows That Would Not Exist Without The Sopranos

The iconic HBO show, The Sopranos, had a major influence on several TV shows, altering the course of television and who we ultimately root for.

8 Seinfeld

The magic that made this show great would be hard to recreate

As one of the most beloved and influential sitcoms of the 1990s, Seinfeld brought together the perfect storm of talent and timing. However, those holding out hope for a reboot will likely be disappointed as the show’s magic stemmed from a specific era that can’t be recreated. Additionally, Seinfeld revolved around its namesake. A reboot minus the iconic comedian at the center would prove impossible. Like Friends, any attempts to capture Seinfeld’s influence would fare better as a spiritual successor with fresh stories and characters rather than rehashing the near-flawless original. As such, the closest modern incarnation remains Curb Your Enthusiasm by Larry David.

7 Lost

A mystery that has already been solved

When Lost debuted in 2004, its expansive mythology and sprawling ensemble cast stood out as rare accomplishments on television. Now, complex, big-budget dramas such as this are commonplace. Even with more acceptance, Lost remains unlikely to ever see a reboot. The show’s mysteries and character arcs reached definitive conclusions over six seasons, leaving little room for expansion. Its iconic performances would prove difficult to recreate as well, especially with twists and surprises already revealed. Plenty of modern mystery TV shows now emulate the themes Lost excelled at exploring. However, none can capture the precise alchemy of characters, lore reveals, and speculation that made the original series so impactful.

6 The Office

A modern reboot is highly unlikely

Few shows have ever achieved the beloved status of the American adaptation of The Office. However, even with its continued popularity in syndication and streaming, a reboot is improbable. So much of the show’s heart and hilarity sprung from Steve Carell’s legendary performance as bumbling boss Michael Scott. Finding another actor to fill those shoes seems an impossible feat. Many of the original stars like John Krasinski and Jenna Fischer have also affirmed that The Office reached a satisfying conclusion after nine seasons, making a continuation unnecessary. While the mockumentary format and workplace humor remain evergreen, The Office’s one-of-a-kind ensemble and long, complete story arc can never be recaptured.

Related

There Is Only One Way The Office Reboot Can Work (& You May Not Like It)

A potential The Office reboot could go wrong for many reasons, but there is one risky way to bring the series back that could actually work.

5 Oz

What was originally trailblazing content is now commonplace

The groundbreaking HBO prison drama Oz presented gritty portrayals of life behind bars in the late 1990s. However, the harsh realism and violence that originally set Oz apart now pose barriers to the show ever seeing a reboot. Shifting attitudes toward criminal justice and incarceration mean Oz’s unflinching brutality could draw greater backlash. Additionally, few networks today would likely approve another serialized drama set entirely within a correctional facility given their narrow scope. Much of what originally made the show such trailblazing television has since become standard in crime dramas as well. Without the ability to shock and captivate like the original, there seems little incentive to revisit the drama.

4 Friends

A reboot risks tainting an icon

Friends remains etched in sitcom history for its portrait of young adults navigating life and love in 1990s New York City. The show was one of a kind with its strong cast and chemistry. Their era as carefree singles and roommates has passed; recapturing that dynamic later in life could not resonate the same. Likewise, much of Friends’ legacy stems from crystallizing a Gen X experience already reinterpreted by each subsequent generation. While the nostalgia and humor persist in reruns, other sitcoms have since emulated and reimagined its formula for their own eras.

3 The Wire

Unlikely to ever see a revival

More than its characters, The Wire centered its narrative around systemic critiques of bureaucratic institutions and urban American life. The social commentary and allegory proved so dense that the show does not lend itself to continuation; its themes were thoroughly excavated over five seasons with a beginning, middle, and end. While modern television still lacks such bracing examinations into the complex troubles facing cities and those governing them, The Wire said all it needed on those points in its first incarnation. Its niche appeal makes recreating such an unflinching drama improbable as well.

2 Everybody Loves Raymond

A relatable sitcom that ran its course

As a relatable family sitcom, Everybody Loves Raymond seems primed for the revival treatment given to similar shows. However, with numerous cast members sadly deceased, the odds of a reboot appear slim. Much of the show’s humor and heart sprung from Raymond’s interactions with his meddling parents. With Doris Roberts and Peter Boyle both passed on, that crucial dynamic would be lost. Recasting such iconic roles could prove detrimental as well. At this point, a reboot without such pivotal players would likely pale in comparison to the comforts that are still enjoyed in the original reruns.

1 Six Feet Under

A final conclusion with nothing left to tell

Six Feet Under concluded after five seasons with an extensive fast-forward epilogue depicting the deaths of every major character. This unprecedented finale provided meaningful closure for the Fisher family and those who had bonded deeply over five years. Without any narrative threads left dangling, there seems little room or reason to revisit those characters down the line. Reopening such a definitively shut story risks diminishing the poignant note that Six Feet Under ended so purposefully on. Some series finales prove so narratively complete that looking back can only tarnish their legacy, and Six Feet Under strongly stands among them.

Source: BBC